Plant Soil Environ., 2023, 69(3):105-117 | DOI: 10.17221/373/2022-PSE
The effect of deep-tillage depths on crop yield: A global meta-analysisOriginal Paper
- 1 College of Land Resources and Environment, Jiangxi Agricultural University, Nanchang, P.R. China
- 2 Jiangxi Institute of Red Soil, Nanchang, P.R. China
- 3 Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute, Gazipur, Bangladesh
The tillage depth plays a critical role in solving soil compaction - a global problem of soil degradation. However, to date, there are few research reported about tillage depth, and the standard of optimum tillage depth is lacking. Therefore, we conducted a meta-analysis to quantify the effect of tillage depths on crop yield across a global scale, and then to analysis their influence factors such as local climate, soil properties, and managements. Moreover, a global distribution of the optimal tillage depths was estimated by using a random-forest model. Overall, our result demonstrated that crop yield first increased within tillage depths from 25 to 35 cm, and then reduced under higher depth of deep tillage compared to conventional tillage, according to 1109 wheat, maize and soybean (WMS) yield observations from 202 studies and 109 publications. Visibly, 35 cm hence became the optimum tillage depth of WMS across the world, while it varies with different regions. Furthermore, higher crop yields observed in areas with a humid climate, high clay contents, and large bulk density under the optimal depth 40, 35 and 45 cm, respectively. In contrast, a lower yield was observed in areas with arid climates, silty and sandy soils, and lower bulk density within optimal depth of 25 cm, 30 cm, and 25 to 35 cm. Human management efforts, including fertilizer addition, irrigation, straw returning, and changing of cropping system or crop species mostly increased the crop yield under deep tillage. Particularly, our meta-analysis indicated that straw returning needs a greater depth. Finally, we predicted the distributions of optimum depths, which showed that 30 and 35 cm were the optimum tillage depths in the temperate and tropical regions, and the total crop yields of global WMS increased by 2689 million tons per year under the optimal tillage depth, compared with the conventional tillage.
Keywords: conventional tillage; random-forest; best tillage depth; tillage management; subsoiling
Accepted: February 20, 2023; Prepublished online: March 13, 2023; Published: March 28, 2023 Show citation
References
- Adams D.C., Gurevitch J., Rosenberg M.S. (1997): Resampling tests for meta-analysis of ecological data. Ecology, 78: 1277-1283.
Go to original source...
- Adeoye K.B. (1982): Effect of tillage depth on physical properties of a tropical soil and on yield of maize, sorghum and cotton. Soil and Tillage Research, 2: 225-231.
Go to original source...
- Arvidsson J. (1998): Effects of cultivation depth in reduced tillage on soil physical properties, crop yield and plant pathogens. European Journal of Agronomy, 9: 79-85.
Go to original source...
- Arvidsson J., Westlin A., Sörensson F. (2013): Working depth in non-inversion tillage - effects on soil physical properties and crop yield in Swedish field experiments. Soil and Tillage Research, 126: 259-266.
Go to original source...
- Barber R.G., Díaz O. (1992): Effects of deep tillage and fertilization on soya yields in a compacted Ustochrept during seven cropping seasons, Santa Cruz, Bolivia. Soil and Tillage Research, 22: 371-381.
Go to original source...
- Barbosa L.R., Diaz O., Barber R.G. (1989): Effects of deep tillage on soil properties, growth and yield of soya in a compacted Ustochrept in Santa Curz, Bolivia. Soil and Tillage Research, 15: 51-63.
Go to original source...
- Berhe F.T., Fanta A., Alamirew T., Melesse A.M. (2012): The effect of tillage practices on grain yield and water use efficiency. Catena, 100: 128-138.
Go to original source...
- Chandra A., Guru S.K., Thakur T.C. (2017): Impact of different tillage practices on soil biochemical parameters, root and shoot growth and yield attributes of winter wheat. Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry, 6: 1915-1922.
- Chaudhary M.R., Gajri P.R., Prihar S.S., Khera R. (1985): Effect of deep tillage on soil physical properties and maize yields on coarse textured soils. Soil and Tillage Research, 6: 31-44.
Go to original source...
- Chen J., Zheng M.J., Pang D.W., Yin Y.P., Han M.M., Li Y.X., Luo Y.L., Xu X., Li Y., Wang Z.L. (2017): Straw return and appropriate tillage method improve grain yield and nitrogen efficiency of winter wheat. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 16: 1708-1719.
Go to original source...
- Cho H.R., Jung K.H., Zhang Y.S., Han K.H. (2015): Assessment of subsoil compaction by soil texture on field scale. Korean Journal of Soil Science and Fertilizer, 48: 628-633.
Go to original source...
- Cooper J., Baranski M., Stewart G., Nobel-de Lange M., Bàrberi P., Fließbach A., Peigné J., Berner A., Brock C., Casagrande M., Crowley O., David C., De Vliegher A., Döring T.F., Dupont A., Entz M., Grosse M., Haase T., Halde C., Hammerl V., Huiting H., Leithold G., Messmer M., Schloter M., Sukkel W., van der Heijden M.G.A., Willekens K., Wittwer R., Mäder P. (2016): Shallow non-inversion tillage in organic farming maintains crop yields and increases soil C stocks: a meta-analysis. Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 36: 22.
Go to original source...
- Drewry J.J., Lowe J.A.H., Paton R.J. (2000): Effect of subsoiling on soil physical properties and pasture production on a Pallic Soil in Southland, New Zealand. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research, 43: 269-277.
Go to original source...
- Dunker R.E., Hooks C.L., Vance S.L., Darmody R.G. (1995): Deep tillage effects on compacted surface-mined land. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 59: 192-199.
Go to original source...
- Eggelsmann R. (1979): Vom Dampfpflug zum Tiefkulturpflug-Entwicklung und Einsatz. Z. f. Kulturtechnik und Flurbereinigung, 20: 99-112.
- Eswaran P.R.H. (2004): Soil and trouble. Science, 304: 1614-1615.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- EU (2003): The Global Land Cover Map for the Year 2000, 2003. GLC2000 database. Brussels, European Commision Joint Research Centre. Available at: http://www-gem.jrc.it/glc2000
- Evans S.D., Lindstrom M.J., Voorhees W.B., Moncrief J.F., Nelson G.A. (1996): Effect of subsoiling and subsequent tillage on soil bulk density, soil moisture, and corn yield. Soil and Tillage Research, 38: 35-46.
Go to original source...
- Feng Q., An C.J., Chen Z., Wang Z. (2020): Can deep tillage enhance carbon sequestration in soils? A meta-analysis towards GHG mitigation and sustainable agricultural management. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 133: 110293.
Go to original source...
- Fischer G., Nachtergaele F., Prieler S., Van V.H.T., Verelst L., Wiberg D. (2008): Global Agro-ecological Zones Assessment for Agriculture (GAEZ 2008). International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, Laxenburg, Austria and FAO, Rome.
- Gorucu S., Khalilian A., Han Y.J., Dodd R.B., Smith B.R. (2013): An algorithm to determine the optimum tillage depth from soil penertometer data in Coastal plain soils. Applied Engineering in Agriculture, 22: 625-631.
Go to original source...
- Gu Y.B., Liu Y.J., Li J.Y., Cao M.F., Wang Z.H., Li J., Meng D.L., Cao P.J., Duan S.H., Zhang M.F., Tan G., Xiong J., Yin H.Q., Zhou Z.C. (2022): Mechanism of intermittent deep tillage and different depths improving crop growth from the perspective of rhizosphere soil nutrients, root system architectures, bacterial communities, and functional profiles. Frontiers in Microbiology, 12: 759374.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Hammad E.A., Dawelbeit M.I. (2001): Effect of tillage and field condition on soil physical properties, cane and sugar yields in Vertisols of Kenana Sugar Estate, Sudan. Soil and Tillage Research, 62: 101-109.
Go to original source...
- He J.N., Shi Y., Yu Z.W. (2019): Subsoiling improves soil physical and microbial properties, and increases yield of winter wheat in the Huang-Huai-Hai Plain of China. Soil and Tillage Research, 187: 182-193.
Go to original source...
- Hemmat A. (2009): Reduction in primary tillage depth and secondary tillage intensity for irrigated canola production in a loam soil in central Iran. Agricultural Science and Technology, 11: 275-288.
- Henderson D.M., Cox W.J., van Es H.M. (2013): Corn production under three disk chisel depths. Journal of Production Agriculture, 5: 369-373.
Go to original source...
- Hill R.L., Meza-Montalvo M. (1990): Long-term wheel traffic effects on soil physical properties under different tillage systems. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 54: 865-870.
Go to original source...
- Hobbs P.R. (2007): Conservation agriculture: what is it and why is it important for future sustainable food production? Journal of Agricultural Science, 145: 127-137.
Go to original source...
- Hou X.Q., Li R., Jia Z.K., Han Q.F., Wang W., Yang B.P. (2012): Effects of rotational tillage practices on soil properties, winter wheat yields and water-use efficiency in semi-arid areas of north-west China. Field Crops Research, 129: 7-13.
Go to original source...
- Hwang W., Park M., Cho K., Kim J.G., Hyun S. (2019): Mitigation of CO2 and N2O emission from cabbage fields in Korea by optimizing tillage depth and N-fertilizer level: DNDC model simulation under RCP 8.5 scenario. Sustainability, 11: 6158.
Go to original source...
- Jabro J.D., Iversen W.M., Stevens W.B., Evans R.G., Mikha M.M., Allen B.L. (2015): Effect of three tillage depths on sugarbeet response and soil penetrability resistance. Agronomy Journal, 107: 1481-1488.
Go to original source...
- Kahnt G. (1976): Ackerbau ohne Pflug. Stuttgart, Verlag Eugen Ulmer, 128.
- Kladivko E.J. (2001): Tillage systems and soil ecology. Soil and Tillage Research, 61: 61-76.
Go to original source...
- Kothari S.K., Singh C.P., Vijay Kumar Y., Singh K. (2003): Morphology, yield and quality of ashwagandha (Withania somnifera L. Dunal) roots and its cultivation economics as influenced by tillage depth and plant population density. The Journal of Horticultural Science and Biotechnology, 78: 422-425.
Go to original source...
- Kouwenhoven J.K., Perdok U.D., Boer J., Oomen G.J.M. (2002): Soil management by shallow mouldboard ploughing in the Netherlands. Soil and Tillage Research, 65: 125-139.
Go to original source...
- Larney F.J., Fortune R.A. (1986): Recompaction effects of mouldboard ploughing and seedbed cultivations on four deep loosened soils. Soil and Tillage Research, 8: 77-87.
Go to original source...
- Li R.P., Zheng J.Y., Xie R.Z., Ming B., Peng X.H., Luo Y., Zheng H.B., Sui P.X., Wang K.R., Hou L.G., Zhang G.Q., Bai S.J., Wang H., Liu W.R., Li S.K. (2022): Potential mechanisms of maize yield reduction under short-term no-tillage combined with residue coverage in the semi-humid region of Northeast China. Soil and Tillage Research, 217: 105289.
Go to original source...
- Lizumi T. (2019): Global Dataset of Historical Yields v1.2 and v1.3 Aligned Version. Tsukuba, Pangaea, Available at: https://doi.org/10.1594/PANGAEA.909132
Go to original source...
- Lu C.Q., Tian H.Q. (2017): Global nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer use for agriculture production in the past half century: shifted hot spots and nutrient imbalance. Earth System Science Data, 9: 181-192.
Go to original source...
- Mathers A.C., Wilson G.C., Schneider A.D., Scott P. (1971): Sugarbeet response to deep tillage, nitrogen, and phosphorus on Pullman Clay Loam. Agronomy Journal, 63: 474-477.
Go to original source...
- Plouffe C., McLaughlin N.B., Tessier S., Laguë C. (1995): Energy requirements and depth stability of two different moldboard plow bottoms in a heavy clay soil. Canadian Agricultural Engineering, 37: 279-285.
- Prasad A.M., Iverson L.R., Liaw A. (2006): Newer classification and regression tree techniques: bagging and random forests for ecological prediction. Ecosystems, 9: 181-199.
Go to original source...
- Russell E.W. (1956): The effects of very deep ploughing and of subsoiling on crop yields. The Journal of Agricultural Science, 48: 129-144.
Go to original source...
- Salem H.M., Valero C., Muñoz M.Á., Gil-Rodríguez M. (2015): Effect of integrated reservoir tillage for in-situ rainwater harvesting and other tillage practices on soil physical properties. Soil and Tillage Research, 151: 50-60.
Go to original source...
- Sarauskis E., Buragiene S., Romaneckas K., Sakalauskas A., Jasinskas A., Vaiciukevicius E., Karayel D. (2012): Working time, fuel consumption and economic analysis of different tillage and sowing systems in Lithuania. Engineering for Fural Development, 24: 52-59.
- Schneider F., Don A., Hennings I., Schmittmann O., Seidel S.J. (2017): The effect of deep tillage on crop yield - what do we really know? Soil and Tillage Research, 174: 193-204.
Go to original source...
- Shen Y., Zhang T.T., Cui J.C., Chen S.Y., Han H.F., Ning T.Y. (2021): Subsoiling increases aggregate-associated organic carbon, dry matter, and maize yield on the North China Plain. PeerJ 9: e11099.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Sonderegger T., Pfister S. (2021): Global assessment of agricultural productivity losses from soil compaction and water erosion. Environmental Science and Technology, 55: 12162-12171.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Stibbe E., Kafkafi U. (1973): Influence of tillage depths and P-fertilizer application rates on the yields of annua cropped winter-grown wheat. Agronomy Journal, 65: 617-620.
Go to original source...
- Stoessel F., Sonderegger T., Bayer P., Hellweg S. (2018): Assessing the environmental impacts of soil compaction in Life Cycle Assessment. Science of the Total Environment, 630: 913-921.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Sun J.Y., Gao J.L., Wang Z.G., Hu S.P., Zhang F.J., Bao H.Z., Fan Y.F. (2019): Maize canopy photosynthetic efficiency, plant growth, and yield responses to tillage depth. Agronomy, 9: 3.
Go to original source...
- Trabucco A. (2018): Global Aridity Index and Potential Evapo-Transpiration (ET0) Climate Database v2. Sassari, CGIAR-CSI,. Available at: https://cgiarcsi.community
- Trabucco A.Z.R. (2019): Global Aridity Index and Potential Evapotranspiration (ET0) Climate Database v2. figshare. Sassari, Fileset. Available at: https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.7504448.v3. doi.org/ 10.6084/ m9.figshare. 7504448.v3
Go to original source...
- Tracy S.R., Black C.R., Roberts J.A., Mooney S.J. (2011): Soil compaction: a review of past and present techniques for investigating effects on root growth. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 91: 1528-1537.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Van Muysen W., Govers G., Van Oost K. (2002): Identification of important factors in the process of tillage erosion: the case of mouldboard tillage. Soil and Tillage Research, 65: 77-93.
Go to original source...
- Van Oost K., Govers G., de Alba S., Quine T.A. (2006): Tillage erosion: a review of controlling factors and implications for soil quality. Progress in Physical Geography: Earth and Environment, 30: 443-466.
Go to original source...
- Varsa E.C., Chong S.K., Abolaji J.O., Farquhar D.A., Olsen F.J. (1997): Effect of deep tillage on soil physical characteristics and corn (Zea mays L.) root growth and production. Soil and Tillage Research, 43: 219-228.
Go to original source...
- Wang Y.K., Zhang Z.B., Jiang F.H., Guo Z.C., Peng X.H. (2021): Evaluating soil physical quality indicators of a Vertisol as affected by different tillage practices under wheat-maize system in the North China Plain. Soil and Tillage Research, 209: 104970.
Go to original source...
- Yu Q.Y., You L.Z., Wood-Sichra U., Ru Y.T., Joglekar A.K.B., Fritz S., Xiong W., Lu M., Wu W., Yang P. (2020): A cultivated planet in 2010 - Part 2: The global gridded agricultural-production maps. Earth System Science Data, 12: 3545-3572.
Go to original source...
- Zeyada A.M., Al-Gaadi K.A., Tola E., Madugundu R., Kayad A.G. (2017): Impact of soil firmness and tillage depth on irrigated maize silage performance. Applied Engineering in Agriculture, 33: 491-498.
Go to original source...
- Zhang C., Song X.T., Zhang Y.Q., Wang D., Rees R.M., Ju X.T. (2022): Using nitrification inhibitors and deep placement to tackle the trade-offs between NH3 and N2O emissions in global croplands. Global Change Biology, 28: 4409-4422.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY NC 4.0), which permits non-comercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original publication is properly cited. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.